Talking Point: What If A Southampton Villain Returned?

With Toby Alderweireld’s departure and injury to Florin Gardos, Southampton’s defence has been reduced to it’s bare bones, which has coincided with tabloid comments about a certain villain who once played at St Mary’s.

Last season Southampton boasted the second best defence in the league – conceding just 33 goals all season – an achievement that Ronald Koeman and Southampton fans have taken great pride in holding. Sadly however, with the current players that are at the Dutchman’s disposal, it would prove an incredible task to repeat. So much so, that Koeman himself has told the media how the defence is “Too small with Maya and Jose” and that another two centre halfs are required.

Meanwhile some 6,278 miles away from Stadium De Kuip, there has been yet another horror show for Liverpool outcast Dejan Lovren.

How much of a horror show I hear you ask? Being left for dust by a binman named Patrick Ronaldinho to be exact. Fans of the Merseyside club can be heard begging Southampton to take back the Croatian they now label as a “fraud”.

On the surface this looks to be an interesting talking point for any football fan; Southampton need a centre half and Liverpool want shot of Lovren for the right price. That same Lovren who Southampton fans hailed and supported as one of the finest defenders in the league.

So, what if Southampton were to take him back? Would we?

Dejan Lovren’s £20M transfer during the 2014 summer exodus was one that brought a number of emotions to Southampton fans. Anger was the overriding feeling due to the way the Croatian International conducted his transfer; Lovren not only refused to train in order to force his “dream” move but he also made a number of snide remarks about the club. Stating “don’t let small minds ruin big dreams” in reference to the board and even worse, telling fans “My mind is already at Liverpool” whilst under contract at Southampton.

With the current positive feeling and togetherness that has been moulded into the club, bringing in such a hated player will only leave a sour taste in the mouth of fans.

Then came the inability for Southampton fans to hide their spite. That came about purely because we had lost what we believed to be an irreplaceable defender, the man who would end the inconceivable task of fixing Liverpool’s defence.

Oh how times change.  The transfer turned out to be the opposite of what the pundits and fans had predicted. Lovren had built up a formidable partnership with Jose Fonte and yet a year later he still has to make is mark on the Liverpool team, increasingly finding himself on the bench and being pulled off early for poor performances. His time at Liverpool appears to be rather different to what he had imagined, In a recent interview Lovren even seemed to be reminiscing of his time at his previous club, saying  “At Southampton it was different. There was a good atmosphere and I was happy. If I am not playing well, I cannot be happy. I didn’t pretend.”

It’s been fairly evident to Southampton fans as to what has been at the root of the lowering in the standard of Lovren’s performances since arriving at Anfield. During his time at Southampton, Mauricio Pochettino placed strict demanding philosophies on defensive play and ensured clear instructions were made to Lovren. Under Brendan Rodgers however, it has been argued by many that he has shown naivety in recent years over defensive play and many would argue that no single defender has flourished whilst under his management. With this in mind, footballing wise, a return to st Mary’s may not be a bad move – In fact it would be a strong signing, even more so with Ronald Koeman’s management; the Dutchman would not only share his expertise in defence, but also give Lovren the arm around the shoulder that he once had and so desires.

However I strongly emphasize that the transfer would only prove beneficial in a theoretical sense, this is because of a new found weakness in his game… confidence.

Whilst playing for Liverpool it has become known that Lovren crumbled under the new found pressure of being the club’s most expensive centre half ever. With such a large price tag, comes large expectations and Liverpool fans were willing to offer no support when the Croatian failed to hit the ground running. This proved to form a vicious cycle of unhappy fans leading to a fragile Lovren, resulting only in failure. You can therefore only imagine and worry how poorly he would respond to abuse from Southampton fans, if he were to rejoin the Saints with shattered confidence.

In summary IF Lovren does regret the move, IF he wants a fresh start, IF an acceptable deal for all parties can be struck, IF he were to be offered a clean slate, we MIGHT all benefit and the brilliant centre half that saints fans were so sad to lose MIGHT be seen again. Quite frankly there are too many IF’s and MIGHTs  to lead to any other conclusion other than we are halfway through the transfer window and there are newspaper columns to fill and mischief to be had.

Loading...